After the british misfire of three years earlier, the yanks gave it their first try with this outing, and its not much better. There have been many versions of christmas carol, films and plays. But then i have that problem with all the movie versions of christmas carol or scrooge why did i call mr. Ever since its initial printing in 1843, many different versions of this yuletide tale have been adapted to tv, film and everything in between. This ced feature focuses on the three versions of charles dickens a christmas carol available on ced, but in a break with tradition, im expanding the scope of the feature to cover all the visual performances of the dickens tale about which information is still available. It has been made over 20 times, and there are other television versions. A christmas carol has been available in movie form since the 1901. A divas christmas carol 2000, tv movie that premiered on vh1, now on lifetime, portraying vanessa williams in the scrooge role as ebony scrooge, one third of a late80s pop trio called desire and now an egotistical, arrogant, grouchy solo diva. Alistair sim is as marvelously miserly as he is merrily magnanimous. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. In an american town, an old bitter miser is given a ghostly chance at redemption on christmas eve. Pages in category films based on a christmas carol.
Seymour hicks, scrooge 1935 there were a few silent versions, but this. To celebrate the holidays, were looking at the five best film versions of a christmas carol. How many films of a christmas carol have been made answers. Ebbie 1995, a tv movie with the first female portrayal of. As plainly as possible, this version has a charm and beauty that is lacking in the others ive seen. One of the holidays most enduring and endearing classics is charles dickens a christmas carol. Scott and was directed by clive donner, who also edited a 1951 film version of the story titled scrooge. The best movie versions of charles dickens a christmas carol. Filmmakers have produced countless astounding versions of a christmas carol. How many films of a christmas carol have been made.
Various a christmas carol film adaptations also includes. There have been 20 different films based on charles dickenss a christmas carol, if you consider the recent 3d version, disneys a christmas carol, starring jim carrey. Movie versions of a christmas carol readwritethink. We delve back into more than a century of a christmas carol movies to find. Yep, its that time of year every tv channel churns out another version of charles dickens a christmas carol. A christmas carol got the treatment in 1977, and the result is a shadowy, atmospheric version with little in the way of set or special effects, allowing the excellent cast including michael hordem as scrooge to shine. Theres pretty much a version of scrooge for everyone out there, but.
This is film number 7 of 30, the first and original christmas carol. This version of a christmas carol is quite simply the best. How many movie versions of a christmas carol have been made. What makes this one different from all the other versions. A christmas carol is a christmas classic for a reason.
By the way some versions tend to add the classic line god bless us all, everyone. Dec 19, 2017 yep, its that time of year every tv channel churns out another version of charles dickens a christmas carol. Just how many versions of a christmas carol are there. Dec 21, 2018 the muppet christmas carol directed by brian henson released. Ebenezer 1997, a western version produced for canadian tv, starring jack. The muppet christmas carol directed by brian henson released. Alastair sim is absolutely superb as scrooge, constantly disgruntled with the world. The 10 best versions ever made according to imdb nearly 200 years later, charles dickens a christmas carol is one of the most beloved stories of all time and often adapted for film and television. In no particular order, i would like to demonstrate a little culture about the ways christmas is celebrated or is not celebrated throughout five different religions. Its officially christmas season and that definitely means watching so many versions of a christmas carol that youll lose count the visual adaptions, based on the 1843 novella by charles. Being a history of a christmas carol on film by richard jones. A complete ranking of every adaptation of a christmas carol. Reginald owen plays scrooge, and by plays, i mean he stands with his legs apart and bends over a bit.
From the silent film thats the oldest known theatrical adaptation in existence. Dec, 2019 this is arguably the movie version of a christmas carol to which all others are compared. Scrooge 1970 starring albert finney, sir alec guinness, edith evans and kenneth more. This 1984 madefortelevision version stars george c. There are a lot of other versions of this story, a disney cartoon version and a muppets christmas carol and a few others that dont use the christmas carol name but.
Charles dickens a christmas carol and scrooge this ced feature focuses on the three versions of charles dickens a christmas carol available on ced, but in a break with tradition, im expanding the scope of the feature to cover all the visual performances of the dickens tale about which information is still available. A christmas carol alastair sim as ebenezer scrooge. Dec 02, 2018 since publication in 1843, charles dickens a christmas carol has been adapted for film and television countless times incountless different ways. None of the other actors or actresses are as memorable, but they dont need to be. The elementary school i attended had a tradition of showing a different christmas carol each year during the holidays, so. A christmas carol unit study scrooge there are so many versions of a christmas carol that it should be fairly easy to find one to meet your readers needs should you decide to read it, as well. Write specific things you saw while watching the film. Owen is the first american fulllength feature film version of dickens story. For the purposes of this article, we will be looking at the 1951 live action version of the story starring alastair sim as scrooge, and the 2009 cgimotion. Thought i have seen many different versions of this film, this is the first time i have seen this edition, and i must say its. A viewers guide to various versions of a christmas carol.
The following 49 pages are in this category, out of 49 total. Scott, david warner, susannah york, frank finlay, edward woodward and nigel davenport. Now, the original christmas carol, published in 1843, was pretty popular when it came out. Printable a christmas carol unit study resources scrooge. Of very many film adaptations of the book, this movie is the best, due largely to sims portrayal of scrooge, whose transformation from miser to benefactor is most believably played out in this film. Two very old, silent versions of a christmas carol one from 1910 and the other from 1923 are available to stream over at fandor. A christmas carol 1951 starring alastair sim, meryvn johns, michael hordern and glyn dearman 86 min. In the 2009 disneys a christmas carol, gary oldman was the voice for tiny tim. The 5 best versions of a christmas carol cliche mag.
For the purposes of this article, we will be looking at the 1951 live action version of the story starring alastair sim as scrooge, and the 2009 cgimotion capture version from director robert zemeckis. Since publication in 1843, charles dickens a christmas carol has been adapted for film and television countless times incountless different ways. A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best. Movie versions of charles dickens yuletide favourite being a history of a christmas carol on film.
A christmas carol is no exception and maybe that is why i enjoy so many of the movie versions, they all bring a similar story to the screen, for about 9095% of the time but there is those small differences, scenes added, scenes neglected, names given, situations expanded upon, all making for a fine story no matter which version one is viewing. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol. By far, the best presentation of this classic and beloved story. Whichever is your personal favorite, be sure to watch it during this holiday. The infinite versions of a christmas carol owlmanandy writes.
A christmas carol 1908 version which starred thomas ricketts as scrooge. Aug 18, 2015 how many christmas carol movies have there been. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie. How many movie versions of a christmas carol have been. Here is a list of all our christmas carol and scrooge movies. Some religions like the islam do not even celebrate christmas and then you have others, the buddhists, who use the holiday to practice their religion of spreading peace and goodwill. The 6 best a christmas carol movie adaptations ever, ranked. During the movie the narrator would be involed during the whole show. The ghost of christmas past shows his descent from a shunned, lonely boy, blamed by his father for the death of his mother to the moneyobsessed man who puts profit above humanity. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie versions.
A christmas carol 1938 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. The only real problems i have with it is one marley does not get the ghost schedule right, and second tiny tim and the rest of the cratchit family all sound like they came from different parts of great britain. A christmas carol comparing and contrasting the 1951 and. After we listened to the book in its entirety, we watched the jim carey version of the movie. The deceased partner was in his lifetime as mean and miserly as scrooge. This category is for all film adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol, in either theater or television movie form. Dec 25, 2014 a christmas carol is a christmas classic for a reason.
We set out to find 5 of the best versions of a christmas carol. Dickens a christmas carol has plenty of versions, but. A christmas carol coreen catenburg on august 5, 2019 at 11. Movie and tagged a christmas carol, book versus movie, christmas, ghost story, holiday, jim carrey, reason for the season by katharine l bookmark the permalink. Best movie adaptations of a christmas carol thetoptens. The book just had the narrator in th ebeginning of each seen.
With the holiday season around the corner, i thought it would be a fun time to take a look at two filmed versions of a christmas carol, and see how they stack up and compare to one another. In recent weeks ghosts, dozens maybe even thousands of them, have been appearing in my front room. Movie theaters even get in on the act with different takes on the holiday classic. Another key role is played by kathleen harrison as mrs. So on this anniversary of the storys first publication in 1843, lets pit the bestknown versions against each other in a holiday smackdown. Dec 24, 2019 and for every christmas movie, good or bad, theres probably two versions of a christmas carol. Dec 02, 2016 its officially christmas season and that definitely means watching so many versions of a christmas carol that youll lose count the visual adaptions, based on the 1843 novella by charles. Brer rabbits christmas carol 1992, an animated television movie directed by al guest and starring the voice of christopher corey smith as brer rabbit. Dec 18, 2019 the 6 best a christmas carol movie adaptations ever, ranked. Dec 28, 2019 a xmas carol mashupamazing compilation of many different versions of a xmas carol scrooge. A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best collider. A christmas carol comparecontrast worksheet heading. From the 1901 silent film called scrooge, or, marleys ghost to the 2009 full cgi 3d jim carrey version, a christmas carol is adapted for film, television, and stage perennially.
Charles dickens a christmas carol has seen a number of movie. Of course, there are many more versions of a christmas caroltoo many to list here. A christmas carol a 15minute short with marc mcdermott and charles ogle, respectively playing ebenezer scrooge and bob cratchit. The 5 best versions of dickens a christmas carol dad suggests.
On christmas eve, an old miser named ebenezer scrooge is visited by the spirit of his former partner, jacob marley. The biggest difference between the book and the muppet version of a christmas carol was that the movie had a narrator through the whole show. An entirely separate article could be written about adaptations of a christmas carol set in different time periods and locales, like rod serlings antiwar parable carol for another christmas, or the 1975 conservation short the energy carol or even the year 2000 brazilian version depicting the scrooge figure as a drug lord who repents. This past week, i noticed that the wellknown film the christmas carol there are different versions of the movie was shown on television, as it is usually broadcast each year at this time it is what you would call a clean movie with a touching story, and we all know that its fiction. Charles dickens christmas carol and scrooge ced web page. A flintstones christmas carol 1994, an animated television special based on the flintstones series produced by hannabarbera productions. The five best film adaptations of a christmas carol. Movie versions a christmas carol 1938 starring reginald owen, gene lockhart, kathleen lockhart, june lockhart, leo g. It set me wondering about all the different film adaptations there must have been over the years, and so i decided to begin researching the various celluloid. Scott plays scrooge as a real person rather than a caricature. Here are the versions of a christmas carol that wont make you say bah. I was expecting another animated version to arrive from a certain. This is arguably the movie version of a christmas carol to which all others are compared. From musical interpretations to animation and modernday versions, watching their favorites of this beloved christmas tale is a must for millions around the world each year.
323 734 505 873 563 394 1206 1321 1268 231 1065 707 1229 1474 1186 590 1073 252 358 817 1227 1374 1108 1174 862 486 1440 352 1212 1273 493 942 1342 1314